Stately Vs. Menlo Club

Looking to completely change your wardrobe or upgrade it with the best style pieces? All you need is a men's clothing box to do it. While there are many brands you can choose from in the market, let's talk about two of them: Stately and Menlo Club.

They both offer a subscription box for men's clothes that is set to change the way you dress. However, you need to know which is a better choice for you to make an informed decision.

Let's compare both these brands, and then you can decide the one that is suitable for you.

Stately Vs. Menlo Club

Understanding each brand is crucial in making an informed decision. Stately primarily targets men who appreciate high-quality, versatile clothing that caters to various occasions and styles. It's an excellent choice for professionals, fashion-conscious individuals, and those seeking a wide range of brand options.

Menlo Club, on the other hand, is geared towards men who lean towards streetwear and urban fashion trends. If you're someone who prefers a more casual and trendy wardrobe, Menlo Club's offerings may be better aligned with your style preferences.

Let's compare some of the major features of both brands that you will need to take into account before making a decision.


Pricing Structure

When it comes to the pricing structure, Stately and Menlo Club take distinct approaches.

Stately offers four subscription options to suit various style and budget preferences:

  • Sharp Subscription
    • Total Value: $200+
    • Price: $129 per package
    • Package Includes: The Sharp package includes a personally-curated assortment of 3+ pieces, consisting of tops, bottoms, footwear*, and accessories from in-demand brands. With a total value exceeding $200, this subscription is designed to deliver stylish essentials at an affordable cost.
  • Luxe Subscription
    • Total Value: $300+
    • Price: $179 per package
    • Package Includes: The Luxe package takes style to the next level with personally-curated outfits featuring 5+ pieces of premium tops, bottoms, footwear*, and accessories from leading menswear brands. With a total value exceeding $300, this subscription offers premium fashion choices for the fashion-conscious.
  • Regal Subscription
    • Total Value: $600+
    • Price: $299 per package
    • Package Includes: The Regal subscription caters to those who demand the best. It includes personally-curated outfits with premium footwear and 7+ pieces of premium tops, bottoms, and accessories from top menswear brands. With a total value exceeding $600, this subscription ensures you stand out with premium fashion selections.
  • Presidential Subscription
    • Total Value: $1000+
    • Price: $499 per package
    • Package Includes: The Presidential package offers a complete white-glove service. Subscribers receive a styling consultation, and a personal stylist puts together premium, personalized looks that include a suit or outerwear, footwear, and an assortment of tops, bottoms, and accessories. With a total value exceeding $1000, this subscription is for those who seek the pinnacle of men's fashion.


Clothing Style

Stately and Menlo Club cater to different clothing style preferences:

  • Stately focuses on offering a range of classic and contemporary styles, ensuring that you receive clothing items that align with your personal fashion sense. Whether you prefer a sharp, professional look or a casual, laid-back style, Stately's offerings are designed to meet your needs.
  • Menlo Club clothing, on the other hand, has a more casual and streetwear-oriented approach. If you're into urban fashion and trendy street styles, Menlo Club's subscription box might be more in line with your preferences.

It's important to consider your preferences in style when choosing between the two.


Personal Stylist

The presence of a personal stylist can significantly influence your clothing subscription experience.

Stately offers the valuable service of a personal stylist who works with you to understand your style preferences. This service is complimentary, and you can easily communicate with your stylist to provide input or seek recommendations at any time. Having a personal stylist ensures that the clothing items you receive with each box are tailored to your individual fashion taste.

Menlo Club, on the other hand, does not provide a personal stylist service. Instead, you receive clothing items in your box along with styling suggestions via email; most customers receive the same set of clothes each month. This means you may receive items that do not necessarily align with your style, as there is no direct consultation with a stylist, limiting your options.


Frequency of Deliveries

Stately and Menlo Club also differ in how often you receive clothing items. 

Stately offers flexibility with its two subscription options. You can choose to receive a box for men's clothes every one or two months, depending on your clothing needs and budget. This flexibility allows you to customize your subscription to your lifestyle.

Menlo Club follows four curated packages delivery schedules, over the course of a year, sending you 2 – 3 items every few months as part of your membership. This might not be ideal for those who enjoy frequent wardrobe updates but may not suit those who prefer a less frequent delivery schedule.


Range Of Brands

The variety of brands available through a clothing subscription service can greatly impact your style options.

Stately boasts an impressive range of high-end men's clothing brands, so that you will get high-quality clothing items every time in your box. Their selection includes well-known names like Kenneth Cole, Levi's, Ben Sherman, Calvin Klein, and many more. This diverse brand portfolio ensures that you have access to high-quality clothing items that can elevate your outfits.

Menlo Club’s clothing has a more limited range of brands, primarily offering clothing items from the Five Four Group collection. While this may appeal to those who appreciate a specific brand's aesthetics, it does restrict your choices to a smaller set of options, potentially resulting in more repetitive outfits over time.


Returns And Exchange

The ease of returning and exchanging items is a crucial factor to consider in a clothing subscription service.

Stately provides a straightforward and hassle-free return and exchange policy. You can return or exchange items from your box within five days, and no additional fees are charged. This flexibility ensures that you are satisfied with the clothing items you receive.

Menlo Club does offer exchanges, but some subscribers have reported that the process can be less reliable and more challenging than with Stately. Exchanging clothes may not be as straightforward, and you might find yourself with clothing items that don't fully align with your preferences.


Cancellation Process

Canceling your subscription with both Stately and Menlo Club is relatively straightforward, but there are some differences. 

Stately allows you to cancel your subscription at any time with no hidden fees or hassles. You have full control over when you want to pause or stop your subscription, making it a hassle-free experience.

Menlo Club, while allowing cancellations, may require you to go through a customer service process to do so. Some subscribers have reported that canceling with Menlo Club can be a bit more cumbersome compared to Stately's seamless cancellation process.


Final Words

The choice between Stately and Menlo Club ultimately depends on your individual style, budget, and preferences.

Menlo Club offers a fixed monthly fee, a more limited brand selection, and a less direct stylist interaction. Stately, on the other hand, offers flexible subscription options, tiered pricing, personal stylist services, a wide range of high-quality brands, and a seamless return and exchange process.

So, if you want a men's clothing box that checks all your boxes and provides an amazing, affordable service, get your Stately clothing subscription box now!